The Top 20 clubs on 14:50 - Sep 13 with 2033 views | Tonyfromdk | I don’t think this is an accurate survey. When you talk about player’s who have come through our academy. Then Shearer is one, Walcott another . Then you could go to British player’s like Bale. The fact we signed player’s like Shilton , Keegan etc doesn’t mean we supplied England with talent. Its the player’s who came through our youth system who show it actually works being a young player at Southampton |  | |  |
The Top 20 clubs on 16:36 - Sep 13 with 1944 views | dirk_doone | It is an accurate list of players who played for England whilst they were players at the club. The same rules apply to every team in that list. It does not include players who played for England for other clubs but not while they were a player at the club, like Alan Ball at Southampton. There is nothing unfair about it. [Post edited 13 Sep 16:39]
|  |
|  |
The Top 20 clubs on 16:56 - Sep 13 with 1899 views | Tonyfromdk | Okay, you wrote though “producing England internationals “ Which means that list is total ballsh@t Any team can sign a player it doesn’t mean when he plays for his country he’s representing his club. It should be about player’s who have come through the youth system and then played international football [Post edited 13 Sep 17:05]
|  | |  |
The Top 20 clubs on 18:04 - Sep 13 with 1799 views | dirk_doone |
The Top 20 clubs on 16:56 - Sep 13 by Tonyfromdk | Okay, you wrote though “producing England internationals “ Which means that list is total ballsh@t Any team can sign a player it doesn’t mean when he plays for his country he’s representing his club. It should be about player’s who have come through the youth system and then played international football [Post edited 13 Sep 17:05]
|
Take it up with Givemesport if it bothers you that much. They wrote it. You can tell them: I'm really not interested in arguing with you. https://www.givemesport.com/clubs-produced-most-england-players-football-soccer/ [Post edited 13 Sep 18:04]
|  |
|  |
The Top 20 clubs on 18:20 - Sep 13 with 1759 views | Butty101 |
That list is utter bollix. Read the Newcastle bit and it says they produced Alan shearer, tino and Dan burns. 3 players they paid a massive amount of money for. So hardly produced. |  |
|  |
The Top 20 clubs on 18:56 - Sep 13 with 1714 views | Tonyfromdk |
I’m not interested in arguing either. You’re the one who posted “top 20 clubs” who have produced England players. I’ve just said it’s wrong, that’s all. Instead of just shutting me down, explain why you would think that article is gospel. This is supposed to be a chat forum…. |  | |  |
| |