Forum
Reply
Kone/Burrell-the New Allen/Goddard?
at 11:29 9 Oct 2025

This is a forum.

Anyone can put forward any opinion they like.

From time to time you do say some interesting things.

But when anyone disagrees with you it's the following:

- Try to look intellectually superior

- Belittle or demean the other poster's intelligence

- Accuse the other poster of having authoritarian views

- Try to reframe the argument to suggest you meant something else all along

- Resort to gaslighting

- Play the victim when you get a bit of chirp back

Now I'm not going to claim to be perfect.

I have certainly been guilty of poor forum etiquette at times either derailing threads or dragging out arguments to the point where I must seem like a tedious pain in the rear end.

But I try to learn from my mistakes and adapt my behaviour to suit the overall ambience of this forum.

Why don't you try doing the same?

You might get a lot more respect that way.

Now I have certainly dragged this one out too far, so it's going to be my last reply to you on this thread.

The field is yours to have the final word.
[Post edited 9 Oct 11:30]
Forum
Reply
Kone/Burrell-the New Allen/Goddard?
at 11:18 9 Oct 2025

You start this post by saying you're playing a game of opinions.

You conclude by saying that you rest your case.

An opinion is something that isn't backed up by evidence.

Making a case suggests you have presented a rational argument supported by evidence.

So which is it?

You seem confused Chuckles.

Does Stainrod know his Arse from his Elbow?
Forum
Reply
Hammersmith Flyover
at 10:22 9 Oct 2025

It's a proposal in a 15-year Local Plan that the council hopes to have adopted by 2027:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c24r0z812zno

So even if it gets adopted it's probably at least a decade away.

The key line is probably:

"dubbed a "flyunder", would release land for development"

So the lost Victorian street plan would be replaced by blocks of flats!

I have no idea how much a tunnel would cost but they're not cheap. It would probably need significant redevelopment of Hammersmith to help pay for it.

And shouldn't they sort out the bridge first!?

For anyone who lives in the borough and is interested in the 15 year plan there's more information here:

https://www.lbhf.gov.uk/planning/planning-policy/local-plan

PS:

Having taken a quick glance at the plan it seems to also include the Broadway Centre in the proposed redevelopment:

"Hammersmith Flyover, A4 and adjoining land (HRA3) - to include A4 land running from Colet Gardens in the east to the Cromwell avenue underpass in the west. Includes the Hammersmith Gyratory, the Broadway Centre, the area south of Black’s Road to Hammersmith Bridge Road, the British Transport Police Station and adjacent land to the east on Talgarth Road, the Ark and West London Magistrates Court. "
[Post edited 9 Oct 10:29]
Forum
Reply
Kone/Burrell-the New Allen/Goddard?
at 09:43 9 Oct 2025

One of my "overloaded" criteria was lack of pace.

Mbappe is one of the quickest around!

Joao Felix does look like a good shout. But look a bit closer:

- Does have 11 international goals, although I don't think he had any when he got his big move to Atletico

- Does have pace. Not as quick as Mbappe (not many are) but definitely can shift

- Six foot tall so not as tall as a Kane but definitely taller than Allen or Kelman

- Some websites describe him as an attacking midfielder or second striker rather than an out-and-out striker like Allen.

So I'm not convinced but Felix is a good shout.
Forum
Reply
Kone/Burrell-the New Allen/Goddard?
at 22:58 8 Oct 2025

Eze:

- Not a striker

- Not £100m (the figure you proposed as a benchmark)

I really don't see how this can be described as self-serving.

I will repeat the point as your (self) professed mighty intellect can't seem to grasp it:

- It's a comment on the modern game and how things have changed

- It is not a criticism of Clive Allen

You haven't made a case to rest.
Forum
Reply
Kone/Burrell-the New Allen/Goddard?
at 20:55 8 Oct 2025

Kane is 6' 2" and 86kg

Allen was 5' 10"

I don't know how tall you are but 6' 2" is tall in my book

https://fcbayern.com/en/teams/first-team/harry-kane
Forum
Reply
Kone/Burrell-the New Allen/Goddard?
at 20:20 8 Oct 2025

You started by saying Allen would be a £100m striker in the modern game.

You've now dropped to the "tens of millions".

Losing the courage of your convictions Elbow?

Since we have been through this already I will repeat my earlier challenge to you.

Show me a striker who was:

- Not particularly tall

- Not particularly quick

- Had no international goals

- And went in a £100m+ deal

Show me a striker with all of those attributes and I will admit that you are right.
Forum
Reply
Kone/Burrell-the New Allen/Goddard?
at 20:05 8 Oct 2025

I think the young Jimmy Greaves did have a fair bit of pace.

Not so sure about Law.

Greaves had 44 goals in 57 international appearances.

Law had 30 goals in 55 internationals.

Clive Allen never scored for England.

The point I was making about Allen was that he was a good player in his day but the game has changed and he wouldn't be signed by one of the big clubs that pay big money in the modern game.

And looking back Allen never won the league and never played for the biggest clubs in his era.

Greaves and Law did.

So I'm sticking to my guns on this. And don't get me wrong I do like Allen, but he would never have been a £100m+ striker.
Forum
Reply
Kone/Burrell-the New Allen/Goddard?
at 19:56 8 Oct 2025

To put things in context:

Allen and Goddard had spent years developing a relationship in the reserves. They had also just dropped down to the second tier when they tore the league up in 79/80.

Kone and Burrell have just been thrown together and spent last season playing in the third tier.

Kone and Burrell look great and I hope for great things, but I think it's asking a bit much expecting them to have the same impact as Allen and Goddard.

Let them find their own way and hopefully make their own history.
Forum
Reply
Lewis Moody - Englands Rugby Star diagnosed with Motor Neurone Disease
at 13:54 7 Oct 2025

MND (or ALS) seems to be a growing problem for former sports professionals.

In Italy retired footballers have an incidence of ALS six times the national average. And the condition is starting in the mid-forties for former footballers as opposed to mid-sixties for the general population.

There has been a lot of speculation around what is behind this with questions around doping practices of the Italian clubs.

The clubs obviously didn't like accusations of doping and came up with the fertiliser used on pitches as an alternative explanation.

But so far no clear cause has been established:

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2008/oct/08/europeanfootball.serieafootball
Forum
Reply
Players With Wobbly Starts
at 13:44 6 Oct 2025

Agree with you about our miserly defence.

Not so sure about Graham. Although it is a great imponderable.

He did have a great season for Watford the year we went up but he never reached those levels again in his career.

Helguson's goals and hold up play were vital to our promotion and he continued to do the job the following season in the PL.

On balance I think I'm happy we stuck with HH.
Forum
Reply
Déjà vu all over again for Stéphan’s resurgent Rangers – Report
at 13:38 6 Oct 2025

An excellent case for moving to Bristol.

On the flipside the rest of the country would be calling us Welsh and backpacking Australians would be queueing up at our door thinking we were the New New South Wales.

It would be like Earls Court all over again only with better beer.

Great report as always.
[Post edited 6 Oct 14:05]
Forum
Reply
Players With Wobbly Starts
at 12:36 6 Oct 2025

IIRC Helguson was loaned out to Watford for his second season and no one was sorry to see him go.

Helguson did so well at Watford that they wanted to keep him at the end of the season and Neil Warnock was happy to let them have him provided Danny Graham came over to us.

A deal couldn't be done and the rest is history.

A real sliding doors moment.
[Post edited 6 Oct 13:23]
Forum
Reply
Game three - Preview
at 21:43 3 Oct 2025

What's the time period for that graph?

Barnsley had that crazy Covid season in 2020/21 when five subs were introduced and Valerian Ismael had the three forwards charging around like blue-arsed flies for an hour before subbing them all on sixty minutes and throwing on three more Duracell bunnies to charge around and chase everything down.

Facing that as the third game in a three game week can't have been much fun!

Barnsley won 23 games that season and finished in the playoffs

https://www.sportinglife.com/football/league-tables/championship/10/seasons/2020
Forum
Reply
Data Analysis in Sport
at 21:32 3 Oct 2025

Rory Smith in his Expected Goals book talks about Charles Reep and the way his ideas have been misrepresented but he doesn't go into the same detail as that article.

At the bottom of that article it mentions that the author Rob Haywood was working on his own book about the evolution of football data.

I couldn't find the book on Amazon so maybe it never got published but there is a website to accompany it:

https://www.manyimpossiblethings.com/about
Forum
Reply
Data Analysis in Sport
at 17:11 3 Oct 2025

You have to wonder how some of these football insider rumours get started.

I remember a tale about a very young Cesc Fabregas growing up in a remote part of Catalonia but being such a standout talent that even the mighty Barcelona got to hear about it and sent out a scout to give him the once over.

The coach of CF's team got wind of this but didn't want to lose his star player so for the game where he knew the scout was watching he played CF out of position so that he would look like nothing special and get overlooked.

The coach basically wanted to hang on to his star player for another year and was banking on CF being so good that Barcelona would give him another chance a year later.

So getting back to Sadio Mane. Perhaps it was the Saints coaches putting it about he was a wrong un simply because they wanted to keep hold of him for a bit longer!
[Post edited 3 Oct 17:13]
Forum
Reply
Data Analysis in Sport
at 16:38 3 Oct 2025

Expected Goals by Rory Smith gives a good background into how data analysis got a foothold in the game:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Expected-Goals-conquered-football-changed-ebook/dp/B09P

Although he's not afraid to use fifty words where ten will do!

Smith talks a lot about Chris Anderson. He was Professor of Government at Cornell but became so convinced data could change football he tried to buy a club to prove his theories. That proved to be out of his price range but he did have a tough stint as Coventry CEO along the way. He also has a book on the subject:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Numbers-Game-Everything-About-Football-ebook/dp/B00AHO2

Soccernomics by Simon Kuper and Stefan Szymanski is also worth a read:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Soccernomics-Simon-Kuper-ebook/dp/B006PVZ3LE/ref=sr_1_1

If you just want an overview of how xG is calculated then the FBref website has a good page on this:

https://fbref.com/en/expected-goals-model-explained/
Forum
Reply
Oxford Utd Reflection
at 14:38 3 Oct 2025

For anyone who is interested in xG there's a good explanation on FBref:

https://fbref.com/en/expected-goals-model-explained/

I'm sill not convinced but I will save all that for another time and another thread.
[Post edited 3 Oct 14:40]
Forum
Reply
Oxford Utd Reflection
at 13:12 3 Oct 2025

Fair enough.

If Spaghetti_Hoops wants to drop me a DM explaining exactly why I'm an out of touch old Luddite I'll give it a fair hearing.

Or start a separate thread on xG for those who might want an open discussion on the subject.

Now where did I put that abacus....



[Post edited 3 Oct 13:21]
Forum
Reply
Oxford Utd Reflection
at 12:50 3 Oct 2025

I'm not convinced by xG.

I think it's a very crude proxy which takes no account of the quality of the players involved and merely reflects the position on the pitch from where shots are taken and the probability of that shot going in.

But I'm open minded on the subject and happy to learn.

If you think I've got it wrong then please explain.
Please log in to use all the site's facilities

KensalT


Site Scores

Prediction League: 0
TOTAL: 0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2025