Forum
Reply
CONTRARY to FIRM BELIEF
at 14:08 3 Sep 2025

So you're not bothered that Gerry Francis grew up supporting Brentford?

"Personal life
Francis was a Brentford supporter as a youth and his father Roy was a professional at the club in the late 1940s and early 1950s."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerry_Francis

Not having a dig - honest!

Just think our players and managers should be judged just on what they do for us.

Their personal belief, motivations, affiliations etc are their business.

I agree with you about Wilkins not being our best ever, simply because he was too far past his prime and we had to build the side around him.
Forum
Reply
CONTRARY to FIRM BELIEF
at 13:22 3 Sep 2025

Agree with all of that.

He was brilliant at Chelsea. Debut at 17 and Captain at 18. But Chelsea were fairly rank in the seventies and I think he was relegated at least once during his Chelsea playing career.

Ironic that we got more out of him than his boyhood team did.

Man United did not get the best out of him.

Hard to believe now but he was nicknamed "The Crab" during his time at Old Trafford because he was always passing sideways.
Forum
Reply
CONTRARY to FIRM BELIEF
at 11:20 3 Sep 2025

Ray Wilkins didn't just play for Chelsea, he was Chelsea to his core.

So was Terry Venables.

Dave Sexton was arguably our most successful manager and he came to us from Chelsea.

Dave Webb who was at the heart of that '76 defence came to us from Chelsea.

Paul Furlong is still with us but he was previously at Chelsea - and we let him know what we thought about that when he joined us.

There has been a lot of overlap between us and Fulham Broadway FC.

Yes, there have been a few knobs along the way (Hughes, Bosingwa, etc). But some of the biggest names in our history worked for both clubs. And like it or not it has usually been us taking their sloppy seconds.

Off the top of my head the only player who started with us and went on to play for Chelsea was Clive Allen. And Clive seemed to be on some sort of mission to play for every club in London (Us, Arsenal, Palace, Spurs, Chelsea, West Ham, and Millwall)

EDIT -

If we stretch a point Raheem Sterling was with us before joining Chelsea late in his career. He never got to play for us, but he's not likely to be playing for them much either this season.
[Post edited 3 Sep 14:47]
Forum
Reply
3G artificial pitches
at 18:50 2 Sep 2025

The fact it's an old story doesn't mean there isn't anything in it.

The risks of smoking and secondary smoking were known for decades before strict bans were introduced on smoking in public places.

The dangers of asbestos were known as far back as the 1890's but it was still being used in construction up until the 1960's.

In Italy there has been concern about the rates of ALS in former professional footballers whose rates of ALS are double the expected average and where the average age of onset is 45 compared to the national average of onset at 65:

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32321311/

There has been a lot of speculation about what is causing this. One theory suggested it was down to players being given banned performance substances, with or without their consent. Obviously the Italian clubs didn't like that idea and scratched around for other possible causes and came up with fertilisers as a potential cause:

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2008/oct/08/europeanfootball.serieafootball

Whatever the cause Italy does have a big problem with this.

So it might just be a slow news day on the Daily Mail. Then again.....
Forum
Reply
Out of the darkness – Report
at 22:55 31 Aug 2025

Great report Clive.

Very fair all round.

One very small quibble.

Madsen's pass completion of 26/40 is 65%. Bit harsh to say "nearly half his attempts went to Charlton players", especially when he's knocking balls forward and not rehearsing Russell's Martin's "Strictly" routine.
Forum
Reply
Rest of the Championship thread 25/26
at 18:13 29 Aug 2025

Leroy Fer made a career out of PL relegation scraps.
Forum
Reply
In Advanced Talks With Edwards
at 13:00 29 Aug 2025

Much as I like WLS it can be a bit "clickbaity" at times.

If David McIntyre puts his name to an article I tend to take it seriously.

He didn't put his name on this one

https://www.westlondonsport.com/qpr/southampton-reject-offer-from-qpr-for-edward
Forum
Reply
No subject
at 09:48 29 Aug 2025

If there's no subject then I guess it can be anything we want.

That Nathan Jones hair island is coming along nicely.

Another Schteve McClaren in the making.

Forum
Reply
In Advanced Talks With Edwards
at 14:04 28 Aug 2025

Really good point you made on Hoops and Dreams about the model of training players to play out from the back and then selling them to the Premier League isn't going to work anymore because the PL has moved on and become a lot more physical with only Man City still trying to play out from the back.

So playing out from the back doesn't work for us and even if we did manage to get good at it there would be no market to sell the players in.

Why are we still struggling on with it!?
Forum
Reply
In Advanced Talks With Edwards
at 12:41 28 Aug 2025

"Super excited" is the one that grinds my gears.

We're being steadily Americanised.

[Post edited 28 Aug 12:58]
Forum
Reply
Looks like Armstrong is available
at 17:24 27 Aug 2025

I think everything you say is true.

But while he was just a squad player with potential for us he was becoming a cult figure with the Ireland U-21's scoring seven goals in eleven appearances in 2023/24:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinclair_Armstrong

Whoever was advising him probably told him he was too big to be sitting on our bench and needed a move to a better club to fulfil his potential.

And to be fair we probably should have given him a season on loan in League 1 to help his development.

Pace and power can't be taught and he has no shortage of those.

And no one ever questioned his attitude.

It's the ball skills that let him down.

I thought Bristol City and Liam Manning would be a good opportunity for him to develop, but it hasn't worked out.

Difficult to see how he progresses from here.
Forum
Reply
Books
at 16:05 27 Aug 2025

The Three Body Problem is a good one.

I haven't read Walking on Glass but the Culture series by Iain Banks is hard to put down once you get into it

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Culture

They're stand alone stories so don't have to be read in order.
Forum
Reply
In Advanced Talks With Edwards
at 15:45 27 Aug 2025

He's a player Russell Martin would have loved.

But RM ain't at Southampton anymore.

And RM himself said Saints might want to be more physical and athletic in future.

So it's easy to see why Edwards might now be on the fringes at Saints. But they'll still want their money back, and he's still a player who could develop into a top player at the right club.

But dreams cost nothing. If there's a chance of getting him on loan then why not!?
Forum
Reply
Julien Stéphan
at 15:50 25 Aug 2025

They might have been waiting for the Eze deal to go through before finalising the incomings.

Either that or they were being saved up to be unveiled just in time for the open training day to get a few punters in.

Don't be surprised to see Saito announced before the end of today.

Nourry does have form for these smoke and mirrors tricks.
[Post edited 25 Aug 15:58]
Forum
Reply
Question for the stattos
at 13:23 25 Aug 2025

My mistake.

You're right, we conceded 73.

My brain's on Bank Holiday mode!

Nobody likes to see Fulham Broadway FC looking so crap
Forum
Reply
Ben Williams - Disasterclass?
at 13:17 25 Aug 2025

He didn't come across like he wanted to be there.
Forum
Reply
Question for the stattos
at 13:07 25 Aug 2025

You're right. 1978/79 was a bad one.

Conceded 14 in the last five games and 92 in the league that season

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1978%E2%80%9379_Queens_Park_Rangers_F.C._season

Apart from 86/87 mentioned by Dave all the epic bad runs mentioned so far ended in relegation. Hope that's not an omen.
Forum
Reply
Ben Williams - Disasterclass?
at 12:57 25 Aug 2025

Have to hold my hand up and say I was one of those complaining about Williams phoning it in from Dubai whilst juggling other jobs across several time zones.

But now that he's back things seem worse than ever.

So you're right. Questions need to be answered about whether Williams has the right background for this job and why we are piling up injuries and looking completely off the pace.
Forum
Reply
Question for the stattos
at 11:38 25 Aug 2025

2014/15. Harry Redknapp and his "bonus" away games. Don't remind me.

I'm not old enough to remember 1968/69 but I see we conceded 95 goals that season:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1968%E2%80%9369_Queens_Park_Rangers_F.C._season
[Post edited 25 Aug 11:54]
Forum
Reply
Saito
at 10:33 25 Aug 2025

Cifuentes leaving shouldn't be an excuse to be repeating the same old mistakes.

Most of the coaches that were here under Cifuentes are still here.

What's the point in preaching continuity if you keep going back to things that our small army of experienced coaches have already seen don't work.

It looks like pig-headed stupidity.

The Dof looks like he is trying to prove his way was right all along and Marti was wrong to change the system.

Seems Marti is still living rent free inside Nourry's head.
Please log in to use all the site's facilities

KensalT


Site Scores

Prediction League: 0
TOTAL: 0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2025