| Rate the new boys 16:18 - Apr 23 with 2957 views | Gloucs_R |
Out of 10, how would you rate this seasons new signings?
Daniel Bennie (LW | £250k from Perth Glory) 6/10. Young player who needs a loan if I am honest. Decent first season though.
Liam Morrison (CB | undisclosed from Bayern Munich) 9/10. Shame he was injured as he has been outstanding when he has played.
Hevertton Santos (RB | free from Estrela Amadora) 2/10. Looked poor from the beginning and not cut out for English football.
Paul Nardi (GK | free transfer from Gent) 9/10 not perfect but a very good signing and quality kepper for this level.
Zan Celar (CF | £1.7m from Lugano) 5/10 jury is still out. Hope he gets a good preseason in to him.
Jonathan Varane (DM | £875k from Sporting Gijon) 7/10, started slowly but has got better througout the season
Karamoko Dembele (AM | loan from Brest) 7/10 glimpses of a good player, another season affected by his injury
Koki Saito (LW | loan from Lommel SK) 8/10 would like to see him join on a perm
Nicolas Madsen (CM | £3.4m from Westerlo) 4/10 isnt the player I was hoping for and cost a lot of money
Harrison Ashby (RB | loan from Newcastle United) 5/10 some good games but I seem to remember more poor ones |  |
| |  |
| Rate the new boys on 13:23 - Apr 24 with 388 views | TheChef |
Agree with most of these.
I note Saito getting a lot of 8s. More of a 7 for me, very handy player and I hope we sign him permanently, but needs to increase his goals and assists. |  |
| |
| Rate the new boys on 13:29 - Apr 24 with 371 views | numptydumpty |
| Rate the new boys on 12:07 - Apr 24 by robith |
Are we rating how good the signing was or how they played? Cos I don't think any one who has played for us this season deserves higher than a 7 |
Where i work, we regularly offer feedback forms to our clients where they rate us in various areas of our work and from 1 to 10 also.
Often someone else's 8 is another person's 6.
In reality it's hard to assess as everyone thinks differently around numbers.
The words are much more relevant in my experiences... |  |
| |
| Rate the new boys on 13:47 - Apr 24 with 316 views | Superhoop83 |
Nardi 9/10 - not perfect but made a huge difference
Santos 3/10 - would be lower if he hadn't scored in the League Cup
Morrison 9/10 - very, very impressed
Ashby 5/10 - I like him more than some and he's not had a decent run in the side
Varane 7/10 - 8 in some games, 6 in others (more so at the start of the season)
Celar 3/10 - not convinced despite the two goals at Cardiff
Madsen 5/10 - there is definitely a player there, so I'm sitting on the fence
Saito 8/10 - love him and his attitude, which is worth a mark of its own
Dembele 7/10 - I'd love to see him have a good run in the team next season
Morgan 7/10 - same as Varane, except the other way round, and crucial in the turnaround
Lloyd 4/10 - mainly for his work rate |  |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
