| We Got A Live One 20:48 - Aug 29 with 5646 views | BazzaInTheLoft |
I do like a moody manager giving blunt answers
|  | | |  |
| We Got A Live One on 21:04 - Aug 29 with 3976 views | Northernr |
Not an unfair question. Dave’s turn to take it in the teeth for asking it. |  | | |
| We Got A Live One on 21:12 - Aug 29 with 3910 views | Hayesender |
Is there a link to the full interview? |  |
| |
| We Got A Live One on 21:16 - Aug 29 with 3862 views | Toast_R |
Its his decision in as much as Cook heaping praise on Niko Madsen after announcing his 1 more year, was genuinely straight off the cuff.
No one's being leaned on at all.... |  | | |
| We Got A Live One on 21:49 - Aug 29 with 3612 views | ozexile |
Valid question. At least we know where the fault lies now. |  | | |
| We Got A Live One on 21:58 - Aug 29 with 3529 views | dmm |
Is it unfair to think Stephan's answer is what you'd expect him to say? Would or could he ever have said otherwise? |  | | |
| We Got A Live One on 22:05 - Aug 29 with 3448 views | Wilkinswatercarrier |
A tad insulting to ask that question.
Let me put it this way, if Nourry was telling Stèphan who to play, would he really be telling him to pick Cook? | |
| |
| We Got A Live One on 22:35 - Aug 29 with 3230 views | stevec |
| We Got A Live One on 22:05 - Aug 29 by Wilkinswatercarrier |
A tad insulting to ask that question.
Let me put it this way, if Nourry was telling Stèphan who to play, would he really be telling him to pick Cook? |
Well I’m glad somebody asked it.
Had enough of the deflection, JS took the job, JS has to own it. He has, but we’ve suffered 4 games of utter toilet, so if this team doesn’t pick up fast it’s on his watch and the club needs to act appropriately. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| We Got A Live One on 22:41 - Aug 29 with 3193 views | Hunterhoop |
| We Got A Live One on 22:35 - Aug 29 by stevec |
Well I’m glad somebody asked it.
Had enough of the deflection, JS took the job, JS has to own it. He has, but we’ve suffered 4 games of utter toilet, so if this team doesn’t pick up fast it’s on his watch and the club needs to act appropriately. |
Big difference between the question asked (around selection) and the more important question of: "who decided/determined the formation/system and style of play we have employed so far this season?"
I think his answer would have been a lot more telling there...
And I strongly suspect we'll see a change in that tomorrow... |  | | |
| We Got A Live One on 22:55 - Aug 29 with 3114 views | Jimboqpr |
He was never going to say 'Nourry helps me pick the side' was he?! Tbf to him it's not really the people hes picking (Plymouth aside which was ridiculous) thats the major issue for me. It's the way they're being asked to play which annoys me more and the lack of fitness. Maybe asking him whether this style is his idea, or the clubs would've been a better question and given him the chance to anwser a bit more openly. Maybe not though! I don't think hes come across from managing some decent teams in France's top league to a side constantly battling relegation in England's 2nd tier for someone to tell him what team to pick. From listening to what others said about him on Clives pod he can be a very stubborn and strong willed guy, so I don't think I really buy in to this stuff about him not being to pick who he wants. Time will tell though I guess we're only 4 games in. As plenty of others have said tomorrow's team selection is important, but the way they play is even more vital. | | | |
| We Got A Live One on 22:58 - Aug 29 with 3088 views | Padulas_Shampoo |
| We Got A Live One on 22:35 - Aug 29 by stevec |
Well I’m glad somebody asked it.
Had enough of the deflection, JS took the job, JS has to own it. He has, but we’ve suffered 4 games of utter toilet, so if this team doesn’t pick up fast it’s on his watch and the club needs to act appropriately. |
How many failed coaches would it take until we (by we I mean you) consider it might not be the coach that’s the root cause of our lack of success? |  | | |
| We Got A Live One on 23:03 - Aug 29 with 3047 views | loftupper |
The whole thing is ridiculous and insulting to the man!
Like him don't like him, doubt he cares! He does at least deserve some respect for being a professional.
Feels like some are sulking a bit, and not just over last Saturdays result | | | |
| We Got A Live One on 23:08 - Aug 29 with 2987 views | stevec |
| We Got A Live One on 22:58 - Aug 29 by Padulas_Shampoo |
How many failed coaches would it take until we (by we I mean you) consider it might not be the coach that’s the root cause of our lack of success? |
Dunno, but roughly the same amount that came before Stock, Jago, Venables, Francis, Holloway and Warnock.
This fella looks clueless, it’s up to him to show us he’s got what it takes. | | | |
| We Got A Live One on 23:27 - Aug 29 with 2880 views | ozexile |
| We Got A Live One on 22:58 - Aug 29 by Padulas_Shampoo |
How many failed coaches would it take until we (by we I mean you) consider it might not be the coach that’s the root cause of our lack of success? |
The root cause of our lack of success is that we're a small west London Club. The root cause of our lack of fitness, lack of team Unity, and players unable to play 2 passes to each other is down to the coach. No one's demanding success. But we are demanding professionalism [Post edited 29 Aug 23:28]
| | | |
| We Got A Live One on 23:41 - Aug 29 with 2809 views | 100percent |
good - I'm glad someone has asked the question.
Still not totally convinced by his answer, but at the very least it's good to see him feeling uncomfortable about our direct questions regarding our predicament.
The pressure is now on him to deliver the game plan and get a song out of this squad.
If he was under any misconceptions about what's expected - and how long it will take people to question his methodology, he can be in little doubt now.
He needs to prove the doubters wrong starting tomorrow... |  | | |
| We Got A Live One on 00:00 - Aug 30 with 2745 views | Hunterhoop |
| We Got A Live One on 23:27 - Aug 29 by ozexile |
The root cause of our lack of success is that we're a small west London Club. The root cause of our lack of fitness, lack of team Unity, and players unable to play 2 passes to each other is down to the coach. No one's demanding success. But we are demanding professionalism [Post edited 29 Aug 23:28]
|
But for the umpteenth time, “fitness” is not the responsibility of Stephan. In our structure, it lies with Ben Williams, who also reports directly to Nourry. The physios, doctor, and fitness coaches report to Williams, not Stephan.
Whether that is correct structure is a different question.
But we cannot beat Stephan up for the fitness of the players. This isn’t the 90s and 00s when Gerry and Ollie ran pre-seasons (sadly). | | | |
| We Got A Live One on 00:04 - Aug 30 with 2728 views | Beckenhamhoop |
| We Got A Live One on 22:35 - Aug 29 by stevec |
Well I’m glad somebody asked it.
Had enough of the deflection, JS took the job, JS has to own it. He has, but we’ve suffered 4 games of utter toilet, so if this team doesn’t pick up fast it’s on his watch and the club needs to act appropriately. |
By ‘act appropriately’ I presume you mean sack him? | | | |
| We Got A Live One on 00:18 - Aug 30 with 2681 views | BazzaInTheLoft |
Regardless of what he said, are we really buying that he’s choosing to play Walsh? | | | |
| We Got A Live One on 01:00 - Aug 30 with 2527 views | stainrods_elbow |
| We Got A Live One on 22:58 - Aug 29 by Padulas_Shampoo |
How many failed coaches would it take until we (by we I mean you) consider it might not be the coach that’s the root cause of our lack of success? |
Why do you make the fundamentalist assumption that there's a single 'root cause'? A successful football team/club is a complex weave. |  |
| |
| We Got A Live One on 01:01 - Aug 30 with 2523 views | stainrods_elbow |
| We Got A Live One on 00:18 - Aug 30 by BazzaInTheLoft |
Regardless of what he said, are we really buying that he’s choosing to play Walsh? |
So he's a liar then, you mean? | |
| |
| We Got A Live One on 01:39 - Aug 30 with 2452 views | Match82 |
| We Got A Live One on 00:00 - Aug 30 by Hunterhoop |
But for the umpteenth time, “fitness” is not the responsibility of Stephan. In our structure, it lies with Ben Williams, who also reports directly to Nourry. The physios, doctor, and fitness coaches report to Williams, not Stephan.
Whether that is correct structure is a different question.
But we cannot beat Stephan up for the fitness of the players. This isn’t the 90s and 00s when Gerry and Ollie ran pre-seasons (sadly). |
Honestly there's probably not any club in the top few divisions that doesn't have a fitness coach these days. Not many of them get to do their job from Dubai mind you. |  | | |
| We Got A Live One on 01:55 - Aug 30 with 2424 views | ozexile |
| We Got A Live One on 00:00 - Aug 30 by Hunterhoop |
But for the umpteenth time, “fitness” is not the responsibility of Stephan. In our structure, it lies with Ben Williams, who also reports directly to Nourry. The physios, doctor, and fitness coaches report to Williams, not Stephan.
Whether that is correct structure is a different question.
But we cannot beat Stephan up for the fitness of the players. This isn’t the 90s and 00s when Gerry and Ollie ran pre-seasons (sadly). |
I know full well what the structure is. But if you imagine that Stephan isn't talking to Williams and the physios then you're in cloud cuckoo land. And another reason it's his responsibility is because he'll be the one on the guillotine if we carry on as we are. [Post edited 30 Aug 1:57]
| | | |
| We Got A Live One on 02:12 - Aug 30 with 2387 views | FredManRave |
| We Got A Live One on 00:18 - Aug 30 by BazzaInTheLoft |
Regardless of what he said, are we really buying that he’s choosing to play Walsh? |
Good point. The original closed question asked was a waste because there was only ever going to be one answer.
A better thought out open question along the lines of, "Can you please explain the reasons behind your decision to drop Nardi for Walsh" or something similar, would have been much better. |  |
| |
| We Got A Live One on 05:41 - Aug 30 with 2182 views | Rsole |
| We Got A Live One on 01:39 - Aug 30 by Match82 |
Honestly there's probably not any club in the top few divisions that doesn't have a fitness coach these days. Not many of them get to do their job from Dubai mind you. |
Ndidi - but only QPR can claim to have an unfitness coach that cramps everyone’s style.
 |  |
| Those possessed by devils, try and keep them under control a bit, can't you ?
|
| |
| We Got A Live One on 07:01 - Aug 30 with 2041 views | dmm |
| We Got A Live One on 01:55 - Aug 30 by ozexile |
I know full well what the structure is. But if you imagine that Stephan isn't talking to Williams and the physios then you're in cloud cuckoo land. And another reason it's his responsibility is because he'll be the one on the guillotine if we carry on as we are. [Post edited 30 Aug 1:57]
|
Of course Stephan will be talking to Williams, as he will with Nourry, De Souza, Diarra et al. But that doesn't mean he has the authority to change the system on his own. He doesn't.
Stephan would have been shown how the club was set up when he took the job on and he's choosen to work with it. I think the club's structure isn't unusual in Europe so he wouldn't have necessarily thought it was a problem. However, structure is one thing, people are another. The issue is Nourry who is at the top of the tree and in control of things for which he is unqualified and inexperienced. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
