| Celar 12:04 - Aug 25 with 4917 views | alexferguson60 |
According to West London Sport 3 clubs are in for Celar, although no deal has been done.
The bidding must be on who QPR can pay more to get him out the door in a reverse bidding war..... |  | | |  |
| Celar on 09:21 - Aug 26 with 1642 views | Northolt_Rs |
| Celar on 08:31 - Aug 26 by londonscottish |
Kevin Gallen nailed it on the WLS podcast. Said loads of other teams had (a) been drawn to his stats (b) gone to see him (c) run a mile. |
Which implies nobody from the club ever went to actually watch him play before signing him. That’s can’t possibly be true, surely? |  |
| Scooters, Tunes, Trainers and QPR. |
| |
| Celar on 09:24 - Aug 26 with 1604 views | EuroRanger |
No ill will from me. Looked like he could score goals if given supreme service, but that was never going to fit with us. Hope he does well in Germany and earns us a tidy transfer fee so that we can recoup some of the money spent. | | | |
| Celar on 10:12 - Aug 26 with 1453 views | robith |
| Celar on 08:31 - Aug 26 by londonscottish |
Kevin Gallen nailed it on the WLS podcast. Said loads of other teams had (a) been drawn to his stats (b) gone to see him (c) run a mile. |
Gallen is always a genius after the fact |  | | |
| Celar on 10:26 - Aug 26 with 1396 views | QPRSam |
| Celar on 10:12 - Aug 26 by robith |
Gallen is always a genius after the fact |
Tough one as loved him as a player, but see him a whole lot more when we're on a bad run. Hindsight is nice, but I'm not going to dogpile the club for failing with a transfer, does any have 100% hit success? For every Madsen and Celar there will be a Morrison and Varane. Hopefully he does well and we can recoup some money with the buy option | | | |
| Celar on 11:32 - Aug 26 with 1212 views | nick_hammersmith |
| Celar on 10:26 - Aug 26 by QPRSam |
Tough one as loved him as a player, but see him a whole lot more when we're on a bad run. Hindsight is nice, but I'm not going to dogpile the club for failing with a transfer, does any have 100% hit success? For every Madsen and Celar there will be a Morrison and Varane. Hopefully he does well and we can recoup some money with the buy option |
Yeah, even Brentford and Brighton have signed some stinkers.
I think the media like clubs to spend loads of money, it makes excitement for them.
Don't hear too much about Sheff Utd spending all that money on Brewster for example.
So far all our flops like Washington have been pretty small outlays for the Championship, so the element of risk is higher. |  | | |
| Celar on 11:41 - Aug 26 with 1138 views | rbee |
Isn't Gallen employed as a scout these days? If so he would likely hear about these things. |  | | |
| Celar on 13:44 - Aug 26 with 1033 views | robith |
| Celar on 11:41 - Aug 26 by rbee |
Isn't Gallen employed as a scout these days? If so he would likely hear about these things. |
Yeah but he never shares his wisdom at the time, always once they've failed.
Almost like he has an axe to grind | | | |
| Celar on 13:52 - Aug 26 with 978 views | PhilmyRs |
| Celar on 13:44 - Aug 26 by robith |
Yeah but he never shares his wisdom at the time, always once they've failed.
Almost like he has an axe to grind |
I think he offers hints of his underlying views though. I'm sure early on he was noting Celar didn't seem particularly quick or able to hold onto the ball and bring others into play, so noted he'd likely be reliant on service - which for a club like us isn't an ideal situation.
He has constantly banged the drum of us needing 4 strikers, like Luton had when they returned to the premier league. So, while he's not said early on "Celar isn't very good and I would never have bought him if I had a choice", I did suspect he wasn't a fan. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Celar on 14:15 - Aug 26 with 882 views | wombat |
| Celar on 10:26 - Aug 26 by QPRSam |
Tough one as loved him as a player, but see him a whole lot more when we're on a bad run. Hindsight is nice, but I'm not going to dogpile the club for failing with a transfer, does any have 100% hit success? For every Madsen and Celar there will be a Morrison and Varane. Hopefully he does well and we can recoup some money with the buy option |
fair diff in how much we spent on morrison and varanne though
how much did we pay for madson and celar ? 5 million both longish term contracts was the rumour , so an expensive mistake on both of them , |  |
| |
| Celar on 14:18 - Aug 26 with 845 views | Hooping_Mad |
| Celar on 10:26 - Aug 26 by QPRSam |
Tough one as loved him as a player, but see him a whole lot more when we're on a bad run. Hindsight is nice, but I'm not going to dogpile the club for failing with a transfer, does any have 100% hit success? For every Madsen and Celar there will be a Morrison and Varane. Hopefully he does well and we can recoup some money with the buy option |
Works PT for WSL
Bit difficult to report on a good run the last few seasons in his defense. God forbid he actually knows what he's talking about. | |
| |
| Celar on 14:23 - Aug 26 with 805 views | QPRSam |
| Celar on 14:15 - Aug 26 by wombat |
fair diff in how much we spent on morrison and varanne though
how much did we pay for madson and celar ? 5 million both longish term contracts was the rumour , so an expensive mistake on both of them , |
Fair and I think they've learned from their mistakes, but it's probably more commendable to find value out of the cheaper signings like we've done with those and Morgan for example. My early assumption is that their potential value would far surpass the money we spent on Madsen and Celar | | | |
| Celar on 18:47 - Aug 26 with 525 views | QPunkR |
| Celar on 08:53 - Aug 26 by SydneyRs |
Basically Celar was like signing Adam Czerkas again. |
That's unfair to Czerkas - he wasn't a multi-million, much heralded capture |  |
| |
| Celar on 19:02 - Aug 26 with 457 views | CateLeBonR |
| Celar on 08:53 - Aug 26 by SydneyRs |
Basically Celar was like signing Adam Czerkas again. |
Different position I know but it reminds me more of the Ariel Borysiuk signing. |  | | |
| Celar on 19:05 - Aug 26 with 428 views | CiderwithRsie |
| Celar on 02:26 - Aug 26 by turnsey |
Conversely, he scored 51 in 116 in all competitions for Lugano in the Swiss League. It isn't like he's some kind of fraud who wondered into professional football by mistake, but he looks completely wrong for the Championship. Similar to Madsen.
I just scanned Fortuna Dusseldorf's squad list and Celar will be lining up with Jordy De Wijs. Perhaps they can bond over shared past trauma. |
Yeah, this is very much my view.
Some people talk as if he's utterly useless, but no-one's going to be buying him on the basis of last season, they'll be looking at his previous history and seeing an opportunity to get a proven striker for a cheap fee.
Not suggesting that he's some sort of Lost Striker for us, he doesn't seem to fit either the league or the way we play, but there's no reason he can't do well in the German 2nd tier. | | | |
| Celar on 19:29 - Aug 26 with 339 views | NorthantsHoop |
Just not the right player for us, it is just one of those things. Some work out some don't and in a way glad he has secured a new chance for himself. He never really looked happy in a QPR shirt, probably better suited to 2nd tier European football. |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
